Agreement and Resolution — In the Matter of: Peter Edward Rose, Manager, Cincinnati Reds Baseball Club (August 23, 1989, Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, A. Bartlett Giamatti)
From WikiLeague, the free baseball governance encyclopedia.
The Agreement and Resolution between Peter Edward Rose and Commissioner of Baseball A. Bartlett Giamatti, signed August 23, 1989 and faxed to all major-league clubs on August 24, 1989 at 9:00 a.m. ET. The Agreement resolved the Commissioner's six-month investigation of Rose (instituted March 6, 1989) concerning allegations that Rose 'engaged in conduct not in the best interests of baseball in violation of Major League Rule 21, including but not limited to betting on Major League Baseball games in connection with which he had a duty to perform.' The investigation produced the May 9, 1989 Dowd Report (225 pp + 7 volumes of exhibits, by Special Counsel John M. Dowd; in archive at `../reports-and-investigations/1989-05-09_report_dowd-rose-investigation`). Under the Agreement, Rose agreed: (1) to submit to the Commissioner's sole and exclusive jurisdiction; (2) to dismiss with prejudice the civil action Peter Edward Rose v. A. Bartlett Giamatti, No. A8905178 (Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio), removed to S.D. Ohio Docket No. C-2-89-577; (3) to forgo a hearing and offer no defense to the allegations; (4) to accept the Commissioner's penalty without challenge and not to institute any legal proceedings against the Commissioner, any of his representatives, MLB, or any MLB Club. In return, the Commissioner agreed that he would 'not make any formal findings or determinations on any matter including without limitation the allegation that Peter Edward Rose bet on any Major League Baseball game' — the Agreement is explicitly silent on whether Rose bet on baseball, even as it imposes the strongest possible discipline. **The disciplinary sanction**: Rose is 'hereby declared permanently ineligible in accordance with Major League Rule 21 and placed on the Ineligible List.' Rose retains the right to apply for reinstatement under Major League Rule 15(c), but agrees not to challenge or appeal any future Commissioner's evaluation of any such application. **The Agreement was the first active-player lifetime gambling ban under modern MLB rules** — followed 35 years later by the June 4, 2024 Marcano gambling ban (the next active-player lifetime ban for gambling; in archive). Rose never sought reinstatement under Rule 15(c); he died September 30, 2024, still on the Permanently Ineligible List. The Hall of Fame separately adopted Rule 3(E) in February 1991 making any player on the Permanently Ineligible List ineligible for Hall of Fame consideration — the so-called 'Pete Rose rule' — which has since governed Hall eligibility for Rose, the 1919 Black Sox, and others.
Background
Phase 2 wantlist hit cleared. The Pete Rose Agreement and Resolution is the operative 20th-century gambling-discipline precedent in MLB and the foundational document for every modern active-player gambling-discipline case — most directly invoked in the June 4, 2024 Marcano lifetime ban (in archive at 2024-06-04_decision_manfred-marcano-gambling-suspensions). Doctrinal significance: the Agreement's signature structure — Rose accepts permanent ineligibility under Rule 21 in exchange for the Commissioner not making formal factual findings, with the right to apply for Rule 15(c) reinstatement preserved but the procedure for evaluating such reinstatement explicitly committed to the Commissioner's sole discretion — established the modern template for negotiated gambling-discipline closures. The Hall of Fame consequence: in February 1991, the Hall of Fame Board adopted Rule 3(E) ('the Pete Rose rule') making any player on the Permanently Ineligible List ineligible for Hall of Fame consideration. The rule was adopted shortly before Rose would have first appeared on the BBWAA ballot in 1992. Rose never sought Rule 15(c) reinstatement; he died September 30, 2024. Commissioner Giamatti died 8 days after signing the Agreement, on September 1, 1989, of a heart attack at his summer home in Edgartown, Mass. Deputy Commissioner Fay Vincent (witness signatory on this Agreement) became Acting Commissioner immediately and was elected Commissioner on September 13, 1989 — meaning Vincent was the commissioner for the operational duration of Rose's discipline before Vincent's own removal in September 1992 over the unrelated owner-collusion / collective bargaining matters. Procedural footnote on the signed original: the only known signed original of the Agreement was sold at Goldin Auctions in November 2024 (private collector, sale price not publicly disclosed). The fax-copies that went to MLB clubs on August 24, 1989 are presumably preserved in MLB and team archives but not publicly hosted in scanned form. Why the carve-out for Rule 15(c): the reinstatement right was preserved because Major League Rule 15(c) is the structural reinstatement mechanism for any Permanently Ineligible List subject; the carve-out preserves form (Rose can apply) while making substance unreviewable (Rose cannot challenge denial). Rose's applications, if any, are not part of the public record.
Key provisions
- Section 1 (Jurisdiction): Rose 'recognizes, agrees and submits to the sole and exclusive jurisdiction of the Commissioner' (A) to investigate any act, transaction or practice charged, alleged or suspected to be not in the best interests of baseball; (B) to determine, after investigation, what preventive, remedial, or punitive action is appropriate.
- Section 2 (Litigation Dismissal): Rose's counsel executed a stipulation dismissing with prejudice the civil action Peter Edward Rose v. A. Bartlett Giamatti, No. A8905178 (Hamilton County, Ohio), removed to S.D. Ohio Docket No. C-2-89-577.
- Section 3 (No Hearing): 'Peter Edward Rose will not avail himself of the opportunity to participate in a hearing concerning the allegations against him, or otherwise offer any defense to those allegations.'
- Section 4 (No Challenge): 'Peter Edward Rose acknowledges that the Commissioner has a factual basis to impose the penalty provided herein, and hereby accepts the penalty imposed on him by the Commissioner and agrees not to challenge that penalty in court or otherwise.'
- Section 5 (Commissioner's Authority Acknowledgement): 'The commissioner recognizes and agrees that it is in the best interests of the national game of Baseball that this matter be resolved pursuant to his sole and exclusive authority under the Major League Agreement.'
- Disciplinary Sanction (a): 'Peter Edward Rose is hereby declared permanently ineligible in accordance with Major League Rule 21 and placed on the Ineligible List.'
- Reinstatement Right (b): 'Nothing in this Agreement shall deprive Peter Edward Rose of the rights under Major League Rule 15(c) to apply for reinstatement. Peter Edward Rose agrees not to challenge, appeal or otherwise contest the decision of, or the procedure employed by, the Commissioner or any future Commissioner in the evaluation of any application for reinstatement.'
- Silence on Underlying Facts (c): 'Nothing in this agreement shall be deemed either an admission or a denial by Peter Edward Rose of the allegation that he bet on any Major League Baseball game.'
- Public Statements: Either party may make public statements about the matter so long as such statements do not contradict the terms of the Agreement.
Notable provisions
On March 6, 1989, the Commissioner of Baseball instituted an investigation of Peter Edward Rose, the field manager of the Cincinnati Reds Baseball Club, concerning allegations that Peter Edward Rose engaged in conduct not in the best interests of baseball in violation of Major League Rule 21, including but not limited to betting on Major League Baseball games in connection with which he had a duty to perform.— Agreement and Resolution, In the Matter of Peter Edward Rose, Aug. 23, 1989, at 1
Peter Edward Rose will conclude these proceedings before the Commissioner without a hearing and the Commissioner will not make any formal findings or determinations on any matter including without limitation the allegation that Peter Edward Rose bet on any Major League Baseball game.— Agreement and Resolution, In the Matter of Peter Edward Rose, Aug. 23, 1989, at 2
Peter Edward Rose is hereby declared permanently ineligible in accordance with Major League Rule 21 and placed on the Ineligible List.— Agreement and Resolution, In the Matter of Peter Edward Rose, Aug. 23, 1989, Section (a)
Nothing in this agreement shall be deemed either an admission or a denial by Peter Edward Rose of the allegation that he bet on any Major League Baseball game.— Agreement and Resolution, In the Matter of Peter Edward Rose, Aug. 23, 1989, Section (c)
Further context
Rose-Giamatti Agreement and Resolution (Aug 23, 1989)
The operative 20th-century gambling-discipline document in MLB and the foundational precedent for every modern active-player gambling-discipline case. Phase 2 wantlist hit cleared.
The disposition, in one sentence
Peter Edward Rose is declared permanently ineligible in accordance with Major League Rule 21 and placed on the Ineligible List — with the right to apply for reinstatement preserved but the Commissioner's evaluation of any such application explicitly committed to be unchallengeable.
The negotiated structure
The Agreement's signature feature is its silence on the underlying facts. The Commissioner agreed not to make any formal findings on whether Rose bet on baseball, and the Agreement is explicitly neither an admission nor a denial of that allegation. In exchange, Rose accepted the strongest possible discipline (permanent ineligibility) and dismissed his pending state-court suit.
The doctrinal benefit of the structure: the Commissioner's office obtained discipline without the evidentiary hearing risks of a contested proceeding; Rose obtained the smallest possible formal record acknowledging his conduct. Both sides got what they negotiated for.
What this document is to subsequent commissioner discipline
This is the template. The 2024 Marcano lifetime ban (same Rule 21, same permanently-ineligible disposition) is the direct doctrinal descendant. The 2020 Astros decision (different rule, "best interests" authority, but similar negotiated-immunity-and-cooperation framework) sits in the same lineage.
The Hall of Fame consequence
In February 1991, the Hall of Fame Board adopted Rule 3(E) — known as "the Pete Rose rule" — making any player on the Permanently Ineligible List ineligible for Hall of Fame consideration. Rose never sought Rule 15(c) reinstatement during his lifetime. He died on September 30, 2024, still on the Permanently Ineligible List.
Verification status
needs_review — Baseball Almanac is a single secondary reproduction of high quality but secondary. Promotion to verified requires either the Agreement-as-exhibit in the Rose v. Giamatti court filings (S.D. Ohio Docket C-2-89-577) or the Goldin 2024 auction-scan of the original signed pages. A scan or transcription from the Hall of Fame Library would also suffice.
Related documents in the archive
../reports-and-investigations/1989-05-09_report_dowd-rose-investigation.md— the underlying 225-page investigative report (with 7 volumes of exhibits) by Special Counsel John M. Dowd that triggered this Agreement.2024-06-04_decision_manfred-marcano-gambling-suspensions.md— the modern doctrinal descendant; the second active-player lifetime ban for gambling, 35 years after this Agreement.2020-01-13_decision_manfred-astros-sign-stealing.md— the modern non-gambling Best Interests application using a similar negotiated-cooperation-and-immunity framework.
References
- Primary source: baseball-almanac.com — Office of the Commissioner of Baseball (faxed to all major-league clubs on August 24, 1989 at 9:00 a.m. ET); the only known signed original was sold at Goldin auction in November 2024, retrieved 2026-05-18.
- Confirmation source: baseball-almanac.com — Baseball Almanac (baseball-history reference site, operating since 1999). HTML reproduction of the full 5-page Agreement and Resolution text, including signature blocks. Retrieved via mcp__workspace__web_fetch on 2026-05-18 and transcribed verbatim. Baseball Almanac is the most accessible public reproduction; it is a secondary source — the lineage to a primary source is asserted ('full text from a five page fax often referred to as the Pete Rose / A. Bartlett Giamatti Agreement, as preserved by Baseball Almanac. The final document was faxed to each major league club on August 24, 1989, at 9:00 a.m. Eastern Standard Time.') but the original signed paper document is not publicly hosted.
- File fingerprint: SHA256 5a1f3a7a59a86f1023f0296fd1798c092b9bc01064ecd7c702e4b3f43fb1f07b.
Evidence trail
Per archive editorial standards §1.3 and §1.4, verified documents require two independent confirmation sources and an archive.org snapshot. This panel is the integrity record the archive holds for this document.
File integrity
- SHA256
5a1f3a7a59a86f1023f0296fd1798c092b9bc01064ecd7c702e4b3f43fb1f07b- Filename
1989-08-23_agreement_rose-giamatti-permanent-ineligibility.txt- Format
- TXT · 6.80 KB
- Retrieved
- 2026-05-18 by
claude/cowork-9167cb28 - Primary URL
- https://www.baseball-almanac.com/players/p_rosea.shtml
Confirmation sources (1)
| Publisher | Retrieved | URL | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baseball Almanac (baseball-history reference site, operating since 1999) | 2026-05-18 | https://www.baseball-almanac.com/players/p_rosea.shtml | HTML reproduction of the full 5-page Agreement and Resolution text, including signature blocks. Retrieved via mcp__workspace__web_fetch on 2026-05-18 and transcribed verbatim. Baseball Almanac is the most accessible public reproduction; it is a secondary source — the lineage to a primary source is asserted ('full text from a five page fax often referred to as the Pete Rose / A. Bartlett Giamatti Agreement, as preserved by Baseball Almanac. The final document was faxed to each major league club on August 24, 1989, at 9:00 a.m. Eastern Standard Time.') but the original signed paper document is not publicly hosted. |
Most recent status change
needs_review on 2026-05-18 by claude/cowork-9167cb28.
**Phase 2 wantlist hit cleared.** Full 5-page Agreement text retrieved via Baseball Almanac and transcribed to plain text. Status held at `needs_review` rather than `verified` pending a second independent source — Baseball Almanac is a secondary reproduction; promotion to `verified` requires either the Rose v. Giamatti court-filing exhibit (S.D. Ohio Docket C-2-89-577) or the Goldin 2024 auction-scan of the original signed pages.