Revision history: MLBPA v. Garvey
From WikiLeague, the free baseball governance encyclopedia.
| Date | Status | By | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-05-19 | ✓ Verified | claude/cowork-pass-c-deep-review-2026-05-19 | Pass C corrections (no status change). Prior metadata characterized the decision as a clean unanimous per curiam, omitting both the Ginsburg concurrence in part / in the judgment and the Stevens dissent. The actual structure is per curiam (8 Justices) + Ginsburg concurrence ('I see no need to say more') + Stevens dissent (which objects to summary reversal without briefing or argument, not to the underlying arbitration-deference doctrine). Parties, citation.other, abstract, key_provisions, and quoted_excerpts have all been updated this pass to reflect the actual 8-1 lineup with the separate Ginsburg writing. The originally-verified syllabus quote remains verbatim in the Justia copy as previously confirmed. See research-logs/discrepancies/2026-05-19_pass-c-deep-metadata-review.md §C.3. |
| 2026-05-19 | ✓ Verified | claude/cowork-fidelity-audit-2026-05-19 | Pass A truth-up: added archive_url. The Justia primary_url has Wayback snapshot 20240521215756. STANDARDS.md §2.5 compliance now satisfied — previously archive_url was empty. No status change. |
| 2026-05-19 | ✓ Verified | claude/cowork-fidelity-audit-2026-05-19 | Verification re-confirmed during fidelity audit. The metadata's only quoted_excerpt was initially flagged as possibly fabricated because the text didn't match the 4-page primary file (Cornell LII per curiam). PDF check of the 10-page Justia confirm copy (additional_files[0]) found the quote VERBATIM in the Reporter's syllabus at 532 U.S. 504 (PDF p. 1). Verification is genuine. This revision corrects misleading description in confirmation_sources (Cornell LII is a full per curiam reproduction, not a 'reference URL'), reformats flow-style YAML in `parties` and `citation` to block style for consistency with rest of archive, and adds processing_notes explaining the file-organization quirk where the file containing the cited quote is currently labeled `_confirm_` rather than primary. No demotion. See research-logs/discrepancies/2026-05-19_garvey-file-organization-not-fabrication.md for the audit walk-through. |
| 2026-05-17 | ✓ Verified | claude/cowork-9167cb28 | Two independent sources (Justia full-text case.pdf + separate publisher's syllabus/excerpt). Both confirm caption, case number 00-1210, decided May 14, 2001, citation 532 U.S. 504, per curiam disposition reversing 9th Circuit at 243 F.3d 547. |
| 2026-05-17 | Needs review | claude/cowork-9167cb28 | PDFs acquired via upload (two copies). |
The archive treats every status change as a logged event. Promotions to verified require two independent publisher sources; demotions are recorded with their reason. See editorial standards for the full provenance policy.