Revision history: 2002-2006 MLB Basic Agreement
From WikiLeague, the free baseball governance encyclopedia.
| Date | Status | By | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-05-19 | Needs review | claude/cowork-pass-c-deep-review-2026-05-19 | **Demotion.** Pass C deep textual review found this file does not meet STANDARDS.md §6's required-content bar for `verified` status. Three issues: (1) **`key_provisions` carries explicit placeholder text** — `key_provisions[12]` reads '[Articles XIII through XXVIII and Attachments — including the Joint Drug Prevention and Treatment Program — not yet itemized in this metadata pass; full structural mapping requires future content review.]' (2) The single `quoted_excerpts` entry is cited as 'per BoB description; text in archive PDF' — soft hedging for a `verified` excerpt where the schema expects verbatim confirmation. (3) `notes` contains an interpretive historical claim ('first time since 1972 that MLB had avoided a labor stoppage in a CBA-expiration cycle') that is at best debatable: the 1976 CBA followed a spring 1976 owner lockout; the 1990 CBA followed a 32-day spring 1990 owner lockout. Per CLAUDE.md §1.8 this kind of editorial framing is not appropriate for the archive's metadata anyway. The two-source confirmation work is sound; re-promotion requires Article-by-Article structural mapping against the PDF, verbatim verification of the preamble quote, and removal of interpretive scenery. See research-logs/discrepancies/2026-05-19_pass-c-deep-metadata-review.md §C.8 and §D. |
| 2026-05-17 | ✓ Verified | claude/cowork-9167cb28 | SABR independent confirmation copy retrieved — same 234-page document, different PDF encoding. Two independent secondary sources for the same underlying CBA. Promoted to verified. |
| 2026-05-17 | Needs review | claude/cowork-9167cb28 | PDF acquired via user upload (BoB Wayback origin); SHA256 computed; pages 1-3 of TOC reviewed (Articles I-XII visible). Second-source confirmation pending. |
The archive treats every status change as a logged event. Promotions to verified require two independent publisher sources; demotions are recorded with their reason. See editorial standards for the full provenance policy.